Compare Hinayana and Mahayana Buddhism. Why did Buddhism become popular and decline subsequently?

  Hinayana and Mahayana are the two main branches of Buddhism. Hinayana (or Theravada) focuses on personal nirvana through strict self-discipline. Mahayana views the Buddha as divine, practices idol worship, and follows the path of the Bodhisattva to help all beings. Buddhism rose through social equality and royal patronage, but declined due to corruption, internal splits, and a Hindu revival.

 

Comparing Hinayana and Mahayana
  • View of the Buddha: Hinayana sees Gautama Buddha as a human teacher. Mahayana views him as a divine savior or god.
  • Goal of Salvation: Hinayana seeks individual freedom (Arhat ideal). Mahayana seeks universal salvation for all people (Bodhisattva ideal).
  • Rituals and Images: Hinayana rejects idol worship and complex rituals. Mahayana embraces statues, idol worship, and mantras.
  • Language: Hinayana uses Pali for its texts. Mahayana uses Sanskrit.
  • Regions: Hinayana spread to Sri Lanka and Southeast Asia. Mahayana spread to China, Japan, Korea, and Tibet.


Why Buddhism Became Popular
  • Rejection of the Caste System: It welcomed people from all social ranks and ignored rigid birth rules.
  • Simple Teachings: Early teachings used local spoken languages (Prakrit/Pali) instead of elite languages, making it easy to understand.
  • Royal Support: Powerful kings like Ashoka and Kanishka helped spread the message and build monasteries.
  • Ethical Appeal: It offered a middle path focused on personal peace without costly animal sacrifices.
Why Buddhism Declined in India
  • Loss of Royal Support: Later rulers gave land and money to other groups, mostly revived forms of Hinduism.
  • Corruption in Monasteries: Wealth grew inside large monasteries, leading monks to live in luxury and lose their strict discipline.
  • Hindu Assimilation: Hinduism absorbed the Buddha as an avatar of Vishnu and adopted local peaceful ideas, drawing people back.
  • Internal Divisions and Shifts: Splitting into complex sects like Vajrayana and using elite Sanskrit for Mahayana texts distanced the religion from common people.
  • Foreign Invasions: The destruction of major learning centers and monasteries by invading armies broke the organized network of monks. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]