HOW IS INDIAN SECULARISM DIFFERENT FROM THE NOTION OF SECULARISM IN THE WEST?


           Secularism is the principle of the separation of government institutions and persons mandated to represent the state from the religious institutions and dignitaries.
Models of secularism
1.     USA
·        There is a complete separation or mutual exclusion between politics and religion.
·        The state does not adopt any religion as the state religion
·        No one shall be discriminated on the basis of religion
·        It does not prohibit people from expressing religious sentiments in public sphere unless they break any law.
          Thus there exists arm length distance between religion and politics and can be termed as soft secularism


.

.

2.     France
·        There exists a separation of state and religion
·        It does not promote any one religion or discourage any as long as beliefs and practices do not interfere with state or with other citizens rights
·        Due to its commitment to total separation between religion and state, overt religious activities and symbols are banned in public sphere (public schools, public areas etc)
         This is termed as one sided distance or hard secularism.


.

.

1.     India
         India’s secularism is rooted in its unique socio – historic circumstances such as religious diversity, freedom struggle which advocated for equal respect and support for all the religions.
·        The wall of separation between state and religion is porous. Religion cannot interfere in state matters but state can interfere in religious matters to give progressive voice within every religion. Ex – abolition of untouchability (Article 17), Triple talaq bill
·        It provides equal protection by the state to all religions through article 25
·        Acceptance of both individual and community specific rights though articles 25 to 28. Ex – establishment of religious educational institutions
·        It positively interferes with religion such as allowing Khalsa tradition in Sikhism.
          Indian secularism maintains principled distance which means state tries to balance different ambiguous but equally important values which make our secular principles contextual and ethically sensible.


.

.